A points program for your restaurant: how to design it step by step

A well-designed loyalty program tells your best customers that you recognize them and that coming back pays off. Done badly, it’s a permanent discount that eats into your margin. Here’s how to design one: which model to choose, what to reward, what rewards to give and what mistakes to avoid.

Dependienta de heladería entregando un cucurucho a una clienta habitual sonriente

In 30 seconds

  • Three models: redeemable points, tiers you climb by ordering, and cashback as account credit. You can combine them.
  • Reward what matters to you: repeat orders, ordering through your channel, coming in at quiet times. Never reviews.
  • The best rewards cost little and are highly wanted: your own products, free delivery, early access.
  • Set an expiry date, use rules people can grasp in ten seconds, and track what gets redeemed.

What a points program is (and what it isn’t)

A points program rewards customers for coming back: every order adds up and, when they reach a certain amount, they get a reward. It’s the best-known type of loyalty program, but not the only one.

What it shouldn’t be is a permanent discount in disguise. If the program is so generous that customers only come for it, you’ve bought their visit, not their loyalty. The balance you’re after: a lot of value for the customer and little real cost for you.

Points, tiers or cashback: which model to choose

ModelHow it worksProsCons
Redeemable pointsEvery euro or every order earns points; points are redeemed for rewards.Easy to understand and to measure.Once points are redeemed, the balance resets to zero and the customer may lose interest.
Tiers (and seasons)Ordering moves you up a tier; each tier has its own perks. With seasons, progress resets periodically.Sets your best customers apart and gives them a status they don’t want to lose.Takes a bit more explaining and follow-up.
CashbackEvery order gives back a percentage as credit for the next one.Immediate: the reward is felt from the second order.If the percentage is high, it looks a lot like a discount.

Many restaurants combine them: cashback for everyone, which gives an immediate reason to come back, and tiers for regulars, which makes them feel part of something. Seasons help keep the program from going stale: each season can have its own rewards, and everyone starts with the same chance to move up.

5 decisions to make before you launch

1. What behavior you reward

The usual approach is to reward spend or number of orders. But you can steer the program toward what matters to you:

  • Ordering through your own channel, where an order leaves you more margin than on an app charging a commission of up to 30%, delivery included.
  • Coming in or ordering at quiet times (extra points on a Tuesday night).
  • Trying new dishes on the menu.

Don’t reward reviews. Google’s policy prohibits offering discounts, free products or money in exchange for posting reviews, and also asking only happy customers for them.

2. How points are earned

The rule has to make sense in ten seconds: “one point per euro,” “move up a tier with 5 orders in the season,” “we give you back 5% as credit.” If it needs explaining, it doesn’t work.

3. What rewards you give

The best ones aren’t the most expensive, but the ones customers want and that cost you little:

  • An item from your menu: a dessert, a drink, a starter or your signature dish.
  • Free delivery on the next order.
  • Early access to new dishes or limited editions.
  • A status perk: priority reservations or an off-menu dish for the top tier.

The more closely tied to your product, the better: it strengthens your brand instead of turning you into “the discount place.”

Illustrative example · what a reward costs

Rule: 1 point per euro, reward at 100 points€100 spent

Reward: a dessert with an ingredient cost of €1.50€1.50

Program cost as a share of what the customer spent1.5%

To the customer, the dessert is worth its menu price; to you, its recipe cost. Work out the real cost of each reward with your recipe costing.

4. When it expires

Points or credit that never expire are a liability that grows out of control, and they don’t encourage customers to come back soon. Set a reasonable expiry period, state it clearly from the start and send a reminder before it runs out: that reminder is also a good reason to get in touch with the customer.

5. How you promote it

A program nobody knows about doesn’t exist. The bare minimum: a mention on the menu and at the table (QR), on your online store, on your delivery bags, and a message to current customers who agreed to receive communications. Put the terms in writing and make them easy to find.

Mistakes that sink a loyalty program

  • Rewards out of reach. If the first reward comes on the twentieth order, hardly anyone will see it. The first one should come early.
  • Too generous. Work out the cost before you launch, not after.
  • Different rules on each channel with no explanation. If something only applies on your online store or at the table, say so.
  • Running it by hand. Paper punch cards, spreadsheets and a waiter who remembers: it works for the first week.
  • Not looking at the data. If nobody redeems, either the reward isn’t appealing or the goal is too far away.

How to tell if it’s working

Compare, before and after launch, the order frequency of program members, the time between orders and how many rewards get redeemed. If frequency doesn’t move, the program is a cost, not an investment. The metrics are explained in our guide to building customer loyalty for your restaurant.

How Delitbee handles it

The loyalty club works with seasons and tiers: customers move up a tier through points or orders and unlock the rewards you set. It’s included in the Advance plan and currently works on the online store and with table orders. Orders a customer places at your restaurant without going through Delitbee can be added manually to their profile so they count (self-ordering kiosk coming soon). On every plan you can add cashback per brand, with the expiry you choose, and combine it with promotions.

Frequently asked questions

How many points should I give per euro spent?

The simplest option is one point per euro. What matters is working backward: how much spending it takes to reach the first reward and how much that reward costs you. It should come soon, and its cost should be low relative to what was spent.

Is a points program or cashback better?

Cashback is more immediate and easier to understand; tiers do a better job of setting your most loyal regulars apart. You can combine them: cashback for everyone and tiers for those who come back most often.

Should points expire?

Yes, ideally, with a reasonable, clearly communicated period. You avoid building up an uncontrolled liability, and you encourage customers to come back sooner. Send a reminder before they expire.

Can I give points to customers who leave a Google review?

No. Google prohibits offering discounts, free products or any incentive in exchange for reviews. Ask all your customers for feedback, with no reward and without filtering for the happy ones.

Sources

  1. Maps user-generated content policy · Google · incentives and selective reviews
  2. Law 34/2002 on information society services (LSSI) · BOE · Article 21, commercial communications

Informational article, reviewed as of the update date. For drafting your program’s terms and using your customers’ data, check with your accountant or advisor.

Free assessment

Do your best customers know they are?

We help you bring what this article explains to your restaurant, with your numbers and the way you work.

How much of your orders go through delivery apps and what it costs you

What customer data you have today and what you're losing

How to bring repeat customers to your own channel

Free

Pau, Delitbee sales team Dani, Delitbee sales team Her, Delitbee sales team Jesús, Delitbee sales team Genesis, Delitbee sales team

Pau, Dani, Her, Jesús and Genesis

Delitbee sales team

What you get

An estimate of what you can save with your own channel and the first steps to get there

How long it takes

10-15 minutes

Cost

Free and no strings attached